The sensational tire special safeguard case remains in suspense due to China's appeal to the WTO. On December 13, the WTO dispute settlement arbitration panel issued an arbitration report, declaring the United States the winner.
Yesterday (December 14), the head of the Department of Regulations and Laws of the Ministry of Commerce of China expressed regret for the arbitration result and pointed out that China is deeply concerned about the possible negative impact of the expert group arbitration and will carefully study the expert group report and file a complaint in due course to safeguard the legitimate rights and interests of the Chinese industry. At the same time, many domestic companies and tire industry professionals also responded to the case.
An expert told the reporter of the Daily Economic News that it was not surprising that China lost the case. Because WTO arbitration focuses more on "reasonable procedures" and its ambiguity on the details of anti-dumping and anti-subsidy legislation, the WTO is not very authoritative in rulings on such major and sensitive trade disputes.
Fortunately, many tire companies told reporters: "The worst is over."
China's appeal was rejected
The WTO dispute settlement arbitration panel stated that the United States did not violate its obligations when it imposed punitive tariffs on Chinese tires sold to the United States in September 2009 as a "transitional safeguard measure" and was in compliance with the organization's regulations.
The special safeguard case was the first trade dispute between the United States and China after Obama took office, which caused a great uproar. In April 2009, the United Steelworkers Union requested the United States International Trade Commission to impose special safeguard measures such as quota restrictions on tires imported from China on the grounds that "the number of Chinese-made tires sold to the United States has increased significantly, threatening 5,000 domestic jobs in the United States." On September 11, 2009, US President Obama decided to invoke a defense clause in China's accession to the WTO agreement and impose punitive tariffs on all passenger car and light truck tires imported from China for a period of three years. The punitive tariff rate was 35% in 2009, 30% in 2010, and 25% in 2011.
China immediately urged the United States to withdraw the punitive tariffs, but the negotiations between the two sides broke down. After that, China filed a complaint with the WTO and requested arbitration.
The arbitration report published on the WTO website shows that China has failed to prove that the United States has imposed punitive tariffs for longer than the market requires. According to the evidence regulations, the United States does not need to prove the damage caused by the increase in the number of quantified imports. Both China and the United States can appeal the arbitration result within 60 days.
Yesterday, the website of the Ministry of Commerce of China published a response to the incident. The head of the Department of Regulations and Laws of the Ministry of Commerce expressed regret for the WTO arbitration result. The head said that China is deeply concerned about the possible negative impact of the expert group arbitration, and will carefully study the expert group report and file a complaint in due course to safeguard the legitimate rights and interests of Chinese industries.
A person from the Tire Branch of the China Rubber Association also told the reporter from the "Daily Economic News" that if an appeal is made, it will not be too quick and they will make good preparations for the next step.
WTO emphasizes procedures rather than results
The reporter of Daily Economic News saw in the above arbitration report that the Chinese side pointed out in the second summary statement that the decision of the US International Trade Commission is result-oriented and is affected by domestic politics and economy. A key point is that the US pointed out that the export volume of Chinese tires has "grown rapidly". In fact, the number of tires imported by the United States from China has not "grown rapidly". Compared with the increase in 2007 over 2006, the growth rate in 2008 over 2007 was 39% lower. The US International Trade Commission also ignored some important facts, such as the transformation of business strategies will affect the environment and performance of the industry. In fact, the growth of Chinese tire imports has no connection with the performance of the US domestic tire industry, because when the growth of Chinese tire imports was the fastest in 2006-2007, the performance of the US domestic tire industry was actually the best period.
Zhao Zhongxiu, dean of the School of International Economics and Trade at the University of International Business and Economics, also pointed out that the logic of the United States in the special safeguard case was putting the cart before the horse: "In fact, it was the transformation of the tire industry in the United States that caused many processing links to be transferred to China, thus causing the increase in China's tire exports, rather than the increase in China's tire exports leading to the closure of American tire companies."
In fact, the WTO Arbitration Committee is not unaware of this. The reporter of Daily Economic News noted that in the arbitration report, the Arbitration Committee mentioned: "The anti-dumping investigation was initiated by the trade union, not the tire manufacturer itself. The trade union only considered the unemployment caused by the transfer of manufacturing to China. This particularity also raises a proposition for us, that is, the applicability and relevance of safeguards under the trend of globalization and outsourcing. This should be of concern to WTO members."
So why did the WTO rule that China lost the case?
Zhao Zhongxiu pointed out: "The WTO's ruling only concerns whether the procedure is legal, not whether the matter itself is right or wrong."
Huo Jianguo, director of the Ministry of Commerce's International Trade and Economic Cooperation Research Institute, told reporters: "In fact, it is difficult for the WTO to control many of the 'two anti-dumping and one protection' cases initiated by the United States, and it is difficult for us to accuse the WTO of favoring any party. The WTO pays more attention to the legality and compliance of procedures, and does not pay much attention to the results; moreover, the WTO's own rules on anti-dumping and anti-protection are not very detailed. For example, the WTO does not have specific standards for the impact of dumping on domestic industries. This leaves room for countries to operate."
The EU is rumored to follow suit
After the special protection case, China's tire companies can be said to have suffered a baptism.
According to the statistics of the State Customs, from January to October this year, China exported 25.953 million passenger car tires to the United States, a year-on-year decrease of 25.5%; the export value was US$840 million, a decrease of 23%. However, except for the decline in the US market, the export of passenger car tires in other key regional markets increased significantly. From January to October, 36.205 million passenger car tires were exported to Europe, an increase of 41.9%; 12.709 million passenger car tires were exported to Latin America, an increase of 89.1%; and 20.877 million passenger car tires were exported to other parts of Asia, an increase of 38.1%.
"The worst is over," said Chen, manager of the U.S. marketing department of South China Tire Company, China's largest tire exporter, to the Daily Economic News. "In the past year, we have actively explored emerging markets, and now our sales in Eastern Europe, South America and the Middle East are very good. In addition, we are also actively exploring the domestic market. It can be said that we have slowly emerged from the shadow of the special protection case."
Sun Shumin, director of Triangle Tire's International Market Service Department, also told reporters that after a year, the company has basically absorbed the impact of the special protection case and is constantly looking for new market growth points in Europe, the Middle East, Africa, South America and other places.
On the other hand, Zhao Zhongxiu believes that the United States will not become more aggressive because of this case. "The background of the United States launching the special protection case was actually a move by Obama to thank voters after taking office. In the US mid-term elections, the Democratic Party has lost control of the House of Representatives, which has led to some changes in US policies. In addition, the domestic economy of the United States has also improved to a certain extent, and the general tone has gradually changed to cooperation to promote economic development."
The reporter of Daily Economic News learned that although the overall growth of tire exports has shifted the market, it has also caused a chain reaction in other regional markets. "Now the EU has reported that it may conduct an anti-dumping investigation on Chinese tires, and Chinese tires will face a more severe export situation in the future," said a person from a tire company in Xiamen.